Fighting cyber attacks with nuclear weapons

Graham Cluley

Fighting cyber attacks with nuclear weapons

Fighting cyber attacks with nuclear weapons

The New York Times reports that a new strategy could see the United States deploying nuclear weapons in the event of an enemy launching a crippling cyber attack against key infrastructure:

A newly drafted United States nuclear strategy that has been sent to President Trump for approval would permit the use of nuclear weapons to respond to a wide range of devastating but non-nuclear attacks on American infrastructure, including what current and former government officials described as the most crippling kind of cyberattacks.

For decades, American presidents have threatened “first use” of nuclear weapons against enemies in only very narrow and limited circumstances, such as in response to the use of biological weapons against the United States. But the new document is the first to expand that to include attempts to destroy wide-reaching infrastructure, like a country’s power grid or communications, that would be most vulnerable to cyberweapons.

There’s a fundamental difference between meatspace attacks against your country and cyberspace attacks.

It’s much easier with an internet-based attack to hide where the attack originated. Reliable attribution can be a nightmare.

If countries are going to start opening the possibility of launching nuclear counter-attacks if hit by a cyber attack they better be pretty darn sure that they’ve reliably identified who the true culprits are.

Mind you, if we ever come to a time when one country is using nukes to fight internet attacks maybe it doesn’t matter if they blow up the wrong country.

We’ll all be pretty much doomed anyway.

Let’s hope such a strategy never has to be put into action, and that those proposing it are doing so more in an attempt to warn the United States’ enemies against state-sponsored cyber attacks.

Graham Cluley Graham Cluley is a veteran of the anti-virus industry having worked for a number of security companies since the early 1990s when he wrote the first ever version of Dr Solomon's Anti-Virus Toolkit for Windows. Now an independent security analyst, he regularly makes media appearances and is an international public speaker on the topic of computer security, hackers, and online privacy. Follow him on Twitter at @gcluley, or drop him an email.

2 Replies to “Fighting cyber attacks with nuclear weapons”

  1. Evidence of the origins of cyber attacks would be dangerously unclear but why let that stop an ignorant impulsive nut case from having fun?

    1. That's sadly and scarily the question that matters. Would anyone be so stupid to do that? Who can tell? It might be they don't expect it to turn to that but they're not above the temptation either. From the BBC my understanding is it's not as simple as the decision of one person and I can only hope that's the case and those who also would be involved would realise the severity of it (and the criminality of it too). Of course if they don't it wouldn't matter anyway as we'd all be gone soon enough. This world truly is barking mad… and using nuclear weapons is really barking up the wrong tree too. That humans would not be content with splitting the atom is telling but clearly that's the case given thermonuclear weapons exist…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Never miss a thing. Sign up for the free GCHQ newsletter from Graham Cluley.
GET EMAIL UPDATES